WINTER SESSION - CHILLS AND NUMBS THE MIND
By Ruma Dubey
As widely expected, except for a few die-hard optimists, the Winter Session of the Parliament was a complete washout even as Modi gets ready for his Russian tour.
Nothing happened except burning of our hard earned money. The much awaited GST and Land Bill was not even considered, forget debating about it. The LIVE telecast of the proceedings in indeed a revelation – at least we are now able to see how these so called leaders behave, rather, misbehave. This leads us to the question - is the Parliament working or is this a dysfunctional way of working?
The Indian Parliament is currently facing a crisis of confidence. Most of the days, through any session, the Parliament adjourns with no business being done, amidst shouts, sloganeering and a major ruckus. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha, after trying to control the ministers like a teacher trying to bring decorum in an unruly classroom, helplessly, is left with no option but to simply adjourn. Nothing gets done in the Parliament and the common man, looking at the high cost of running the Parliament, apparently around Rs.2.5 lakh per minute, wonders today about the relevance of this institution. The largest democracy in the world - it is shameful how the very edifice of our democracy is today crumbling.
These politicians only shout and disrupt proceedings in the Parliament and as soon as they are out after adjournment, they start debating on TV news channels. If they can debate on TV channels why not where they should actually debate – in the Parliament?
The Parliament has completed 63 years (13th May 1952) and look how much we have fallen in these years! It is assuring to know that unlike neighbouring countries in Asia who go through military coups and violent upheavals, India is more stable and we remain a major democracy. Yet, looking at the current degeneration of this institution, such small consolations become irrelevant. To merely feel good that we have an instrument is futile if the instrument does not work at all.
Do you remember listening to any meaningful debates in either the Rajya Sabha or the Lok Sabha? Yes, those on Women’s reservation Bill, the Lokpal Bill, the Nuclear Bill were good. What we see today is mudslinging with no modicum of parliamentary behavior. Meaningful debates are far and few in between. But a look at all these bills which did get debated happened only because of intense pressure from the people of India, who took to demonstrations and fasting. So the impetus to debate comes from the civil society?
We as people are supposedly powerful as we elect the Govt. But that is the only power we seem to have, which we exercise every five years. After that we have to merely watch the various antics and curse ourselves for even having gone to vote! Why do we have no power but to watch helplessly as these ministers squander away our money and faith in the system? There has to be a change in the way in which Parliament function, a very fundamental change is required. Maybe a new law, maybe a supreme court ruling; something drastic needs to be done to break out from this vicious cycle. The BJP did it when the Congress was in power so now the Congress is giving it back to BJP. But amidst all this politicking, the biggest loser is the country. With no legisaltive action, what is point of any announcement or any Bill getting Cabinet approval?
Modi’s speech of last year, with Make in India and Swachch Bharat; it was a moment of chest thumping. But since then, we have not moved even a block ahead, we are still where we began, maybe two blocks back. We are beyond new slogans and catch phrases – we need action.
Food for thought: the Indian Parliament seems to be unable to break the effect of ‘being a colony’. Why is it that our Ministers still thump the tables like the British instead of, maybe clapping? Or why do they still say, “Aye” when they can say, “yes” when bills are put to vote?